Thursday, June 19, 2014

Book Review: "The Latent Power of the Soul" by Watchman Nee

Having heard about this book from some people, and having my curiosity piqued by it's interesting title, I picked up this short work and read it, only to later put it down in stupefaction. Beware!

Nee's so-called Biblical basis for believing in the latent power of the soul was shockingly speculative and lacking substantial warrant. He claims that Adam must have had supernatural powers, for how else could he have been able to tend to the Garden? On the basis of this reasoning Nee constructs the rest of his book, warning Christians about the latent power of the soul - supernatural powers - that still exists within all humans. Nee attributes the supernatural behavior of Hindus and Buddhists to this latent power of the soul, and states that while God created this power, we no longer have the warrant to utilize it, but Satan wants us to use it to further his ends. Needless to say, with a premise like this, the remainder of the book is chaotic.

Nee is typical of many "deeper life" writers in his day who quote Scriptures to make certain points that are wholly alien to the Scriptures themselves. For some reason these writers were incapable of seeing what they were doing, and wrote with an air of authority which they thought stemmed from God's Word but did not.

Nee actually states that it is possible to pray toward people instead of God, and by simply concentrating on the desire for good or bad things to happen, they will in fact happen. He doesn't encourage us to do this, but states that it works. However, Jesus said, "Which of you, by taking thought, can add one cubit unto his stature?" (Matt. 6:27)

Nee has written some good books which shouldn't be discarded because of this one, but I would never recommend this book of his. It only serves to promote superstition.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Nee's warnings about functioning out of the flesh are in great need. I don't think his statements are that shocking or that speculative. Your reaction to this work seems extreme since you couldn't point out anything unbiblical, nor how it could directly mislead christians today. I can think of many reformed preachers you esteem whom also acted with an authority and said many erroneous things. But I'm not suprised from following your blog thus far that it would end in you knocking Nee.

Eli said...

Hi Anonymous,

Thanks for your comment. I'm not knocking Nee, but Nee's book 'The Latent Power of the Soul'. I found it disturbingly unBiblical since, as I wrote above, it was based upon a speculative foundation. The entire premise was Nee's idea that Adam must have had supernatural powers because otherwise he could not have tended to the Garden of Eden. Apparently the task was too much for him without supernatural abilities such as flight. Based upon this idea, Nee proceeds to write the rest of the book.

I also questioned his idea that we have the power to pray toward ourselves and other people (not God) and achieve miraculous results, by quoting Matthew 6:27. So I did highlight and address some things I deem wrong.

I think Nee has written some good books. 'Sit, Walk, Stand' on Ephesians is good, as well as much in 'The Normal Christian Life'. I get excited whenever I find in Nee those clear explanations of righteousness through faith that are often missing from Christian books. In this he is to be commended.

All the best,
-Eli

Anonymous said...

The entire premise was not simply the idea that Adam tended the garden of Eden. He also named all the animals of the earth. Both of us have names that existed before, but Adam made names from scratch, something few people can manage to do even for one or two children!

And yes, you knock Nee when you generalize him as a "deeper life" writer and with those who, "were incapable of seeing what they were doing, and wrote with an air of authority which they thought stemmed from God's Word but did not."

Keep in mind Nee wrote over 100 books and died in prison for his faith. He is the father of many who believe, and a founder of the underground church in China. Though this particular work of his might be harder for you to swallow, I would be weary of travelling down the road you venture.

Eli said...

I should have clarified: "Nee, in this book, is typical of many "deeper life" writers..."

Brother Greg said...

I love this book! He does explain how the supernatural is so prevalent in Africa and many other countries in the world through false religions. This is something we barely deal with unfortunately in North America so the thinking is foreign to us. Sadly we think from the persecutive of our context locally in the world.
- Greg

Eli said...

I don't deny that the supernatural is prevalent in other parts of the world. I simply deny Nee's explanation as to why that is. I believe Nee's premise is erroneous, that Adam had need of supernatural abilities in order to tend the Garden of Eden. Rather than basing one's doctrine upon a speculation like that, it would be better to attribute the supernatural prevalence in those parts of the world to the activity of Satan and of God, and to the different ways people think.